Cosmo vs. Sports Illustrated for Women
By Sarah
Ever since I was in eighth grade, I’ve been bitten by a pseudo-activist bug. The assistant coach of my soccer team told me and my teammates about a full day conference for teenage girls at the local university. It featured workshops and speakers dealing with a range of issues, from grassroots activism to eating disorders to self defense workshops. Before the conference, I had never really paused to think about activism as it related to me, but walking out of those workshops, I felt bold and powerful and hungry to act.
I joined the group that organized the conference the next year. Activism, as I had spoken or read about, became a reality. I lead a club at my school dealing with women’s issues; I spoke up in discussions. I even bought a t-shirt proclaiming “feminists are HOT…. and bothered”. But I only wore it to school once. Sometimes I got tired of defending my opinions against the cacophony of dissenters. I knew what was right. I stood up for that. But making change is tiring, and sometimes isolating. I was like most high school and middle school-ers, where fading in rather than standing out was often the goal. Inherent to activism is opposing the norm, so what happens when you don’t always feel like fighting? Can you still be an activist?
I believe that you can be. But these questions continue to be dilemmas that I grapple with. I believe that activism can take many forms, and that activists are many types of people. I think that the strength of publications like this blog is their acceptance and celebration of that fact. Like the F-Word, magazines and publications not only present news, opinion and information, but create a relationship with the readers. And through that forum, the questions and dilemmas like mine begin to be resolved.
Sometimes, it felt like magazines promoted the binary I’ve described. I secretly loved glossy gossip magazines. A friend had subscriptions to Seventeen, Cosmo Girl and others, and I would devour them with a staged nonchalance. But reading them I felt that I was cheating another side of myself because I could identify so many instances of articles, advertising and photos that hurt, rather than helped, young women.
And yet, I’ve also found solace in magazines. When I was younger, I subscribed to New Moon, a magazine featuring poetry and short stories written by young girls and whose goal was to empower young women. Later on, I subscribed to Sports Illustrated for Women. I was only in middle school and for some reason I take pride in the fact that I supported such a worthwhile effort. SI for Women focused exclusively on female athletics. Without many pro athletes to profile, college and alternative sport athletes (women who seemed more accessible to young me) were the central focus of the magazine. In those years, the women of the US women’s national soccer team became my idols and celebrities. Those magazines discussed issues from the lens of engaged, thoughtful women. Those magazines gave me a base to critique news and reminded me that I was surrounded by likeminded women all around the world.
Ultimately, I don’t think that there has to be a division between the two types of magazines I’ve described, or between different parts of a personality. When I was younger and starting to explore what it meant to be an activist, I don’t think that I understood that.
F-Word is even more than these magazines, because its online nature allows it to become more than the initial articles. So I hope that in this virtual community, each reader is empowered to be themselves, as active as they feel comfortable.
I leave you with a favorite poem I’ve recently re-discovered. Blessing the Boats by Lucille Clifton feels an appropriate inclusion because it celebrates the faith that one must place in the intangible; in the communities that support you, in the strength of yourself. And furthermore, like the blessing of a new boat, these new posts represent the re-launch of this wonderful F-Word community.
Blessing the Boats
may the tide
that is entering even now
the lip of our understanding
carry you out
beyond the face of fear
may you kiss
the wind then turn from it
certain that it will
love your back may you
open your eyes to water
water waving forever
and may you in your innocence
sail through this to that
-Lucille Clifton